difference between sag and ball mill

What Can Go Wrong in Comminution Circuit Design? - CEEC

ABSTRACT. The design of semi-autogenous grinding (SAG) mill based comminution .... difference in A × b has a significant impact on the subsequent calculated...

Get Price

Optimisation of an industrial scale ball mill using an online pulp and ...

Aug 27, 2009 ... opportunity for optimisation around the industrial scale ball mill was ...... difference between these two is especially pronounced for SAG mills...

Get Price

Rethinking the value of mill relining - Mining Magazine

Nov 3, 2016 ... Semi autogenous grinding (SAG) mills, because of their advantages in .... mill relines at various different sites, and on different sized SAG, ball and .... of mill availability increase makes the difference between staying open and...

Get Price

Impact Load Behavior between Different Charge and Lifter in a ...

Jul 31, 2017 ... This improved understanding of the impact process in the ball mills and also ..... Besides, the difference between experiments and DEM simulation ..... Analysis of Liner Wear Impact on Charge Behaviour in AG and SAG Mills.

Get Price

Autogenous and Semiautogenous mills - zenith

And the product of the large AG/SAG grinding is either a finished size ready of processing, or an immediate size for further grinding in a ball mill, pebble mill, or a...

Get Price

Grinding Mills - Holdtrade (UK) Ltd. Website

A ball mill is a type of grinder used to grind materials like into extremely fine powder ... What''s the Difference between SAG Mills (Semi-Autogenous) and AG mills...

Get Price

SME 2009 Impact on Grinding Mill Design and Recent New ...

At the CIM conference in May 2009, previously unseen differences between macro and micro ... between SAG and ball mills at the design T80 (transfer size).

Get Price

sag mill grinding design versus geometallurgy - Starkey & Associates

Sep 10, 2010 ... When the difference between design methods used by different .... between SAG and ball mill hardness for the majority of the test work data but...

Get Price

startling effect of ball scats removal on sag mill performance

0.5) mill, typical of the majority of SAG mills in the South African gold mining industry. .... difference between extracted scats and replenished new balls. It can be.

Get Price

What''s the difference of Ball mill, SAG mill, AG mill?

The impact can be rock on rock such as in an Autogenous Grinding (AG) mill, rock and a small ball charge (~10%), used in Semi Autogenous Grinding (SAG)...

Get Price

Development of an AG/SAG mill batch test methodology - UQ eSpace

Previous work using pilot scale AG/SAG mill tests with mills between 0.6 and 1.8m in ...... Difference in measured & Morrell power vs Ball:Total vs Speed .

Get Price

using the smc test® to predict comminution circuit ... - SMC Testing

AG/SAG mill and crusher circuit simulations through the use of JKSimMet. .... Note that the Bond ball work index test should be carried out with a closing .... The difference between the two (eq 10 – eq 11) has to be provided by the milling circuit.

Get Price

Discrete Element Simulation of Mill Charge in 3D using the BLAZE ...

Aug 21, 2015 ... semi-autogenous (SAG) mills. .... of a lifter in a ball mill with 3D predictions made with EDEM (author?) ... key difference between (2) and (3) is that during a time step (3) can only slow down a particle but not reverse.

Get Price

SAG and Ball Mills - YouTube

Mar 12, 2015 ... SAG and Ball Mills. Kennecott Utah Copper. Loading... Unsubscribe from Kennecott Utah Copper? Cancel Unsubscribe. Working.

Get Price

difference between of sag mill and ball mill

Mining Industry: What is the difference of ball mill, ... Grinding (SAG) mills, balls of various sizes in Ball Mills and less ... between a ball mill and a .

Get Price

FLzenith breaks world record in Chile — FLzenith Discover Mining

May 1, 2011 ... The 40'' diameter SAG mill and the two 27'' ball mills, installed in ... person, the difference between a 38'' and a 40'' SAG mill is a mere two feet.

Get Price

Gold Fields Granny Smith Grinding Circuit: A ... - SRK Consulting

... through a SAG mill followed by pebble crusher and ball mill (SABC mode). ... Installed grinding power is split equally between the two mills with the SAG mill fitted with a variable speed drive ..... Very little difference was noted overall or from...

Get Price

TECHNICAL NOTES 8 GRINDING RP King - Mineral Technologies ...

LG A mill power equation for SAG mills. Minerals and ... for grate mills K = 9.10. This difference is ascribed to the presence of a pool of slurry that is present on the bottom ... Let VB be the volume of steel balls in the mill, VMed be the volume of...

Get Price

Mining Industry: What is the difference of ball mill, attrition ...

Mar 29, 2016 ... The impact can be rock on rock such as in an Autogenous Grinding (AG) mill, rock and a small ball charge (~10%), used in Semi Autogenous Grinding (SAG)...

Get Price

Minerals | Free Full-Text | Optimizing Performance of SABC ... - MDPI

Dec 2, 2016 ... This circuit shows a semi-autogenous grinding (SAG)/ball mill circuit where .... According to Table 2, differences between the actual equipment...

Get Price

Multi-layer kinematics and collision energy in a large-scale grinding ...

A semi-autogenous grinding (SAG) mill is dependent on rotation to carry the ... Based on the kinematics of the steel balls, the collision energy carried by the outer ... well as the difference of in the collision energy of each layer was tremendous.

Get Price

technical memorandum - SAGMILLING.COM

Nov 11, 2015 ... SUBJECT: SAG MILL + BALL MILL CIRCUIT SIZING ... ticular F80 and P80) is a property of the rock and any difference in specific energy of different comminution .... Partitioning the Total Energy Between SAG and Ball Mills.

Get Price

BALL MILL AND HPGR - Open Collections - University of British ...

focused on the energy and cost comparisons of the existing AG/SAG ball mill circuits ...... Although there is no fundamental difference in the design principle, the...

Get Price

MEI Blog: Comminution ''18 Conference Diary

Apr 29, 2018 ... Ball mills would have dominated comminution conferences little over a ... SAG mills are of major importance, but in his keynote lecture tomorrow, .... changes in the operation of the crusher, due to differences in feed material...

Get Price

Energy and Cost Comparisons of HPGR-based Circuits | E & MJ

Up until now, tumbling mills such as AG/SAG mills and ball mills have had a ... The concept of combining an HPGR and a stirred mill in a single flowsheet has .... So the difference in ball-mill power to reduce the final grind size from 160 to 75...

Get Price

calculation of the required semiautogenous mill power based on the ...

primary wet autogenous mill (WAM) and a series of ball mills. WAM is customary ... material grindability in a certain ore pretreatment machine. For one kind ... the existing techniques of sizing SAG mill power, Bond work in- dexes and their .... P80 is calculated as the difference of the total energy con- sumption in WAM...

Get Price

to download PDF - Ausenco

experimental value of A×b alone (not related to the real differences in ore types ... Another way of determining the power split between the SAG and ball mill...

Get Price

Mill (grinding) - Wikipedia

SAG mills are autogenous mills but use grinding balls like a ball mill. ... Attrition between grinding balls and ore particles causes grinding of...

Get Price

technical memorandum - SAGMILLING.COM

Nov 11, 2015 ... SUBJECT: SAG MILL + BALL MILL CIRCUIT SIZING ... ticular F80 and P80) is a property of the rock and any difference in specific energy of different comminution .... Partitioning the Total Energy Between SAG and Ball Mills.

Get Price

A COMPARISON OF WEAR RATES OF BALL MILL GRINDING ...

difference between the different grades was not as marked. ... SAG mill balls experience both significant abrasive ... lower magnitude than SAG mill balls, due to.

Get Price

Ball Mills vs Rod Mills - 911 Metallurgist

Jul 3, 2017 ... The voids (or interstitial space) within a rod load are approximately half those in a ball mill grinding load. Rods in place weigh approximately...

Get Price

RoM BALL MILLS - A COMPARISON WITH AG/SAG ... - ResearchGate

Ball mills. RoM Ball mills, like SAG mills, utilise coarse rocks in the RoM feed as .... The main difference between the two is that the ratio of steel balls to rock is.

Get Price

Mill (grinding) - Wikipedia

SAG mills are autogenous mills but use grinding balls like a ball mill. ... Attrition between grinding balls and ore particles causes grinding of...

Get Price

Small-Scale Continuous SAG Testing Using the Macpherson ... - SGS

(8%), so it is actually a SAG mill test, but ... autogenous mill, with an 8% ball charge and controlled by sound at 25% mill ... The difference between the highest.

Get Price

What Can Go Wrong in Comminution Circuit Design? - CEEC

ABSTRACT. The design of semi-autogenous grinding (SAG) mill based comminution .... difference in A × b has a significant impact on the subsequent calculated...

Get Price

Optimisation of an industrial scale ball mill using an online pulp and ...

Aug 27, 2009 ... opportunity for optimisation around the industrial scale ball mill was ...... difference between these two is especially pronounced for SAG mills...

Get Price

Rethinking the value of mill relining - Mining Magazine

Nov 3, 2016 ... Semi autogenous grinding (SAG) mills, because of their advantages in .... mill relines at various different sites, and on different sized SAG, ball and .... of mill availability increase makes the difference between staying open and...

Get Price

Impact Load Behavior between Different Charge and Lifter in a ...

Jul 31, 2017 ... This improved understanding of the impact process in the ball mills and also ..... Besides, the difference between experiments and DEM simulation ..... Analysis of Liner Wear Impact on Charge Behaviour in AG and SAG Mills.

Get Price

Autogenous and Semiautogenous mills - zenith

And the product of the large AG/SAG grinding is either a finished size ready of processing, or an immediate size for further grinding in a ball mill, pebble mill, or a...

Get Price

Grinding Mills - Holdtrade (UK) Ltd. Website

A ball mill is a type of grinder used to grind materials like into extremely fine powder ... What''s the Difference between SAG Mills (Semi-Autogenous) and AG mills...

Get Price

SME 2009 Impact on Grinding Mill Design and Recent New ...

At the CIM conference in May 2009, previously unseen differences between macro and micro ... between SAG and ball mills at the design T80 (transfer size).

Get Price

sag mill grinding design versus geometallurgy - Starkey & Associates

Sep 10, 2010 ... When the difference between design methods used by different .... between SAG and ball mill hardness for the majority of the test work data but...

Get Price

startling effect of ball scats removal on sag mill performance

0.5) mill, typical of the majority of SAG mills in the South African gold mining industry. .... difference between extracted scats and replenished new balls. It can be.

Get Price

What''s the difference of Ball mill, SAG mill, AG mill?

The impact can be rock on rock such as in an Autogenous Grinding (AG) mill, rock and a small ball charge (~10%), used in Semi Autogenous Grinding (SAG)...

Get Price

Development of an AG/SAG mill batch test methodology - UQ eSpace

Previous work using pilot scale AG/SAG mill tests with mills between 0.6 and 1.8m in ...... Difference in measured & Morrell power vs Ball:Total vs Speed .

Get Price

using the smc test® to predict comminution circuit ... - SMC Testing

AG/SAG mill and crusher circuit simulations through the use of JKSimMet. .... Note that the Bond ball work index test should be carried out with a closing .... The difference between the two (eq 10 – eq 11) has to be provided by the milling circuit.

Get Price

Discrete Element Simulation of Mill Charge in 3D using the BLAZE ...

Aug 21, 2015 ... semi-autogenous (SAG) mills. .... of a lifter in a ball mill with 3D predictions made with EDEM (author?) ... key difference between (2) and (3) is that during a time step (3) can only slow down a particle but not reverse.

Get Price

SAG and Ball Mills - YouTube

Mar 12, 2015 ... SAG and Ball Mills. Kennecott Utah Copper. Loading... Unsubscribe from Kennecott Utah Copper? Cancel Unsubscribe. Working.

Get Price

difference between of sag mill and ball mill

Mining Industry: What is the difference of ball mill, ... Grinding (SAG) mills, balls of various sizes in Ball Mills and less ... between a ball mill and a .

Get Price

FLzenith breaks world record in Chile — FLzenith Discover Mining

May 1, 2011 ... The 40'' diameter SAG mill and the two 27'' ball mills, installed in ... person, the difference between a 38'' and a 40'' SAG mill is a mere two feet.

Get Price

Gold Fields Granny Smith Grinding Circuit: A ... - SRK Consulting

... through a SAG mill followed by pebble crusher and ball mill (SABC mode). ... Installed grinding power is split equally between the two mills with the SAG mill fitted with a variable speed drive ..... Very little difference was noted overall or from...

Get Price

TECHNICAL NOTES 8 GRINDING RP King - Mineral Technologies ...

LG A mill power equation for SAG mills. Minerals and ... for grate mills K = 9.10. This difference is ascribed to the presence of a pool of slurry that is present on the bottom ... Let VB be the volume of steel balls in the mill, VMed be the volume of...

Get Price

Mining Industry: What is the difference of ball mill, attrition ...

Mar 29, 2016 ... The impact can be rock on rock such as in an Autogenous Grinding (AG) mill, rock and a small ball charge (~10%), used in Semi Autogenous Grinding (SAG)...

Get Price

Minerals | Free Full-Text | Optimizing Performance of SABC ... - MDPI

Dec 2, 2016 ... This circuit shows a semi-autogenous grinding (SAG)/ball mill circuit where .... According to Table 2, differences between the actual equipment...

Get Price

Multi-layer kinematics and collision energy in a large-scale grinding ...

A semi-autogenous grinding (SAG) mill is dependent on rotation to carry the ... Based on the kinematics of the steel balls, the collision energy carried by the outer ... well as the difference of in the collision energy of each layer was tremendous.

Get Price

technical memorandum - SAGMILLING

Nov 11, 2015 ... SUBJECT: SAG MILL + BALL MILL CIRCUIT SIZING ... ticular F80 and P80) is a property of the rock and any difference in specific energy of different comminution .... Partitioning the Total Energy Between SAG and Ball Mills.

Get Price

BALL MILL AND HPGR - Open Collections - University of British ...

focused on the energy and cost comparisons of the existing AG/SAG ball mill circuits ...... Although there is no fundamental difference in the design principle, the...

Get Price

MEI Blog: Comminution ''18 Conference Diary

Apr 29, 2018 ... Ball mills would have dominated comminution conferences little over a ... SAG mills are of major importance, but in his keynote lecture tomorrow, .... changes in the operation of the crusher, due to differences in feed material...

Get Price

Energy and Cost Comparisons of HPGR-based Circuits | E & MJ

Up until now, tumbling mills such as AG/SAG mills and ball mills have had a ... The concept of combining an HPGR and a stirred mill in a single flowsheet has .... So the difference in ball-mill power to reduce the final grind size from 160 to 75...

Get Price

calculation of the required semiautogenous mill power based on the ...

primary wet autogenous mill (WAM) and a series of ball mills. WAM is customary ... material grindability in a certain ore pretreatment machine. For one kind ... the existing techniques of sizing SAG mill power, Bond work in- dexes and their .... P80 is calculated as the difference of the total energy con- sumption in WAM...

Get Price

to download PDF - Ausenco

experimental value of A×b alone (not related to the real differences in ore types ... Another way of determining the power split between the SAG and ball mill...

Get Price

Mill (grinding) - Wikipedia

SAG mills are autogenous mills but use grinding balls like a ball mill. ... Attrition between grinding balls and ore particles causes grinding of...

Get Price

technical memorandum - SAGMILLING

Nov 11, 2015 ... SUBJECT: SAG MILL + BALL MILL CIRCUIT SIZING ... ticular F80 and P80) is a property of the rock and any difference in specific energy of different comminution .... Partitioning the Total Energy Between SAG and Ball Mills.

Get Price

A COMPARISON OF WEAR RATES OF BALL MILL GRINDING ...

difference between the different grades was not as marked. ... SAG mill balls experience both significant abrasive ... lower magnitude than SAG mill balls, due to.

Get Price

Ball Mills vs Rod Mills - 911 Metallurgist

Jul 3, 2017 ... The voids (or interstitial space) within a rod load are approximately half those in a ball mill grinding load. Rods in place weigh approximately...

Get Price

RoM BALL MILLS - A COMPARISON WITH AG/SAG ... - ResearchGate

Ball mills. RoM Ball mills, like SAG mills, utilise coarse rocks in the RoM feed as .... The main difference between the two is that the ratio of steel balls to rock is.

Get Price

Mill (grinding) - Wikipedia

SAG mills are autogenous mills but use grinding balls like a ball mill. ... Attrition between grinding balls and ore particles causes grinding of...

Get Price

Small-Scale Continuous SAG Testing Using the Macpherson ... - SGS

(8%), so it is actually a SAG mill test, but ... autogenous mill, with an 8% ball charge and controlled by sound at 25% mill ... The difference between the highest.

Get Price